Cure Your February Plague With Four Thieves Vinegar

This concoction of vinegar and pungent aromatics was once used to ward off the Black Death

When the Black Death was ravaging medieval and early modern Europe, it was generally thought that such diseases were spread by miasmas of 'foul air'. Aromatised vinegars and other potent-smelling remedies were therefore used to dispel the dangerous vapours — as had been common practice since ancient times.

The so-called Four Thieves Vinegar is one such concoction. The origin of its name is unclear, but the recipe seems to have originated in a French city — either Marseilles or Toulouse — sometime between the 14th and 18th centuries. The name might stem from the group of four thieves who were said to have used it to allow them to rob the sick and dying without contracting plague, or from its supposed inventor, Robert Forthave (get it?). Whatever the original story, the name sounds good, and it has stuck.

Four Thieves Vinegar was traditionally infused with antimicrobial and, crucially, insecticidal herbs such as camphor, rue, and wormwood. Thus, it may indeed have had some ability to protect its users from the plague, which was spread by fleas. The garlic often found in the recipe today is probably a recent addition, reflecting the vinegar's modern transition from aromatic plague-dispeller to popular salad ingredient. (For more historical detail and primary sources, see this excellent writeup by Foods of England.)

In keeping with the 'four thieves' theme — and because I don't have wormwood or rue in my garden — I decided to keep my Fourth Thieves Vinegar recipe simple, using just four readily available ingredients. Use this zingy witches' brew as a tonic in hot water or a unique vinaigrette base.

Ingredients (all quantities are approximate)


De-stem and roughly chop the herbs. Peel and chop the garlic. Add everything to a small jar and fill to the top with vinegar.

Close your jar with a tight-fitting lid, putting a piece parchment paper or clingfilm between the jar and the lid if the latter is metal to prevent corrosion. Leave to sit in a cool dark place for a few weeks, shaking occasionally.

Strain and discard the herbs before using your vinegar. It will keep for a long while but may become cloudy with time.

— Beatrix Swanson

(Image credit: Wikimedia Commons)

Share this post:

Read More News

22 July 2023
Is vinegar good for you?

A brief summary of a long-standing debate

Read More
13 September 2023
Real Honey for Real Vinegar

What makes honey, honey? And why use the good stuff in vinegar making?

Read More
7 January 2024
A Vinegar a Day | 7 January | An Attempt at Asynpoeding

Exploring a surprising South African classic

Read More
1 2 3 16
Copyright © 2021 Tremayne Food and Drink Ltd